Written By: Fiona StockardA member of AA reacts to The NY Times short article around The Center For Motivation and also Change

 Responding to “A Different Path To Fighting Addiction.”

On July third, 2014 Gabrielle Glaser composed an short article for The New York Times entitled, “A Different Path To Fighting Addiction.” In this post, Ms. Glaser profiled The Center for Motivation and also Change (CMC) located in New York City. The CMC rejects the AA version of substance abusage recoexceptionally, instead making use of a “handy, hands on technique to resolving emotional and also behavior difficulties.” It does not ask its patients to swear off chemicals forever.

You are watching: Center for motivation and change reviews


As an energetic member of AA, it was not the idea of “a new way” that carried on my frustration, indeed I love and also welcome new means to gain sober. It was the misguided and also unmoral treatment of the facts that brought about my eyes to roll. The short article seemed even more interested in bashing AA and it’s members, than in presenting the CMC’s treatment ideology.

The Blog post from The Center For Motivation and Change

The short article opens by stating that AA and Al-Anon “Either force them right into rehab or detach till they hit rock bottom.” It goes on to say, “Science tells us those formulas don’t occupational very well.” AA and also Al-Anon don’t say that. In truth, AA and Al-Anon have actually no main position on exactly how to attain long-term sobriety. Some AA and also Al-Anon members hold the check out that hitting bottom and entering a therapy center work-related. The factor they organize this check out is because, well, it functions.

It worked for me. I’m the only perboy who have the right to make the decision to get sober. The alternative is mine and mine only. By letting the results of my addiction hit me square in the jaw, my parental fees provided me every little thing I needed to make the choice to acquire sober. Aget, let me say, this was my route to AA and also not what AA encouraged me to perform. Once I was open up to the concept of recoexceptionally, the twelve actions assisted me discover not just a way to attain and also maintain permanent sobriety, yet a spiritual path to discover my true self.

For the document, what AA actually says is,


1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had actually become uncontrolled.

2. Came to think that a Power greater than ourselves can restore us to


3. Made a decision to revolve our will certainly and our resides over to the treatment of God as we understood Him.

4. Made a browsing and fearmuch less ethical inventory of ourselves.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to one more huguy being the exact nature

of our wrongs.

6. Were totally all set to have God rerelocate all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

8. Made a list of all persons we had actually hequipped, and became willing to make

amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people wherever feasible, except once to do

so would certainly injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and also as soon as we were wrong promptly

admitted it.

11. Sought via prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with

God, as we construed Him, praying only for expertise of His will certainly for us

and also the power to carry that out.

12. Having had a spiroutine awakening as the outcome of these Steps, we tried to

carry this message to alcoholics, and to exercise these ethics in all our


Service Material from the AA General Service Office

That’s what AA claims and also what AA is about. It doesn’t say parents have to “issue edicts, demanding an instant end to all substance use,” or that AA is “an all-or-nopoint commitment for life.” What I discovered is that as soon as I begin to exercise the twelve measures, I didn’t want to live my life any various other method. AA, and also what it actually says, helped me come to be a better perchild. It promoted difficulties much surpassing my alcoholism. AA has given me a “valuable technique to addressing emotional and also behavior problems.” It’s worth noting that this “practical approach” is what The Center for Motivation and also Change clintends to execute. Why, I ask, redevelop the wheel?

Perhaps, bereason as The Center For Motivation and Change claims, “Science tells us those formulas don’t work extremely well.” Let’s examine what exactly science tells us.

In 1956, the Amerihave the right to Medical Association voted to specify alcoholism as a medical illness. The Center For Motivation and Change claims that alcoholism is not an illness. It looks prefer they disagree through science on one major point. They also website many studies that say AA does not work. They’re correct, based upon the researches they made a decision to referral, it doesn’t work-related. In fact, based on a lot of research studies, it appears that AA doesn’t work-related. Here lies the excellent problem of AA facts and numbers, it’s an anonymous programs.

That Facts around The Center For Motivation and Changes Facts

AA members that occupational each action and exercise AA’s principals in their affairs are taught humility and anonymity, for this reason encouraging them to stay quiet around their successes. AA members who attfinish a couple of meetings, don’t occupational the steps, and consequently drink, are even more most likely to stop out. They’re even more likely to blame AA for not working, than to accept individual obligation for their actions.

AA is a regime of action. Our literature says, “Faith without works is dead.” The respanning individual is sindicate a perchild living among you and also working with you. Only once asked for assistance, will certainly our anonymity be broken. That is why research after study paint AA as a faientice.

The just reality that’s proof of AA’s efficiency is the just fact anyone needs to know. In 2006, tright here were a reported 106,202 AA groups global, with a membership totaling 1,867,212 respanning individuals.

See more: Who Sang Hallelujah On American Idol, Contestant Stuns Simon With 'Hallelujah'

That statistic didn’t make it right into the CMC’s post. My question for The Center For Motivation and Change is, scientifically, is it feasible that 1,867,212 people are wrong, and the 25 of you are right?

Doesn’t seem possible.

Gabrielle Glasser’s post is posted here