“Dancing through the Stars” has actually been doing “Disney Night” for a while currently to appease ABC’s corporate emperors. They’ve been doing it for so lengthy that we’ve now checked out two dancers pay tribute to the very same movie in the exact same dance style to the exceptionally exact same item of music. James Van Der Beek closed the display via a “Piprices of the Caribbean” paso doble. Riker Lynch likewise did a “Pirates” paso on “Disney Night” in seachild 20 ago in the spring of 2015. So whose was better? Watch Van Der Beek’s performance above and Lynch’s performance below. Then vote in our poll.

You are watching: Dancing with the stars pirates of the caribbean

Judge Carrie Ann Inaba thought Van Der Beek’s performance was “insane” and also told him, “This was your dance, truly.” Len Goodman believed he was “dramatic” and also “solid,” though there were moments once it can have actually been sharper. Bruno Tonioli called it “grand also spectacle,” a “effective performance,” and a “huge hit.” Inaba and Tonioli offered him 9s while Goodguy provided him an 8, for a total of 26 out of 30.

SIGN UPfor Gold Derby’s totally free newsletter through latest predictions

But the judges were even even more impressed by Lynch’s performance, at least on the basis of their scores. He gained 10s from Inaba and also Tonioli and 9s from Goodguy and also Julianne Hough, that was a full time judge that season. But probably the “Pirates” paso will rotate out to be a good luck charm in the long run. Lynch went on to end up second for the seaboy, shedding the Mirror Ball Trophy to Rumer Willis. Though I guess you can call that a curse, since I’m certain Van Der Beek would rather win than finish second — the “Curse of the Babsence Pearl” perhaps?

Interestingly, Van Der Beek wasn’t the only rerun on “Disney Night” this seachild. Seakid 20 featured Noah Galloway‘s “Aladdin” foxtrot to “A Whole New World”; this week Hannah Brown also perdeveloped an “Aladdin” foxtrot to “A Whole New World.” And that “Disney Night” featured Willis’s “Little Mermaid” samba to “Poor Unfortunate Souls”; this week’s present had actually Lauren Alaina likewise dancing a “Little Mermaid” samba, though to a different song, “Under the Sea.”

SEE‘Dancing through the Stars’ recap: Who carried Mousage House magic to ‘Disney Night,’ and also who (if anyone) went home?

Maybe that’s why Disney really bought 20th Century Fox. It demands even more intellectual residential or commercial property and also dance options for upcoming seasons of “DWTS.”

PREDICT‘Dancing through the Stars’ now; change them until Monday night’s show

Be certain to make your predictions so that the contestants can check out how they’re faring in our racetrack odds. You have the right to save changing your predictions until simply prior to the next episode airs eincredibly Monday on ABC. You’ll compete to win a spot on our leaderboard and eternal bragging civil liberties.

See more: Price Range $$$$ Mean On Facebook, The Complete Guide To The Cost Of Facebook Ads

See our challenge rules and sound off through other fans in our fact TV forum. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.