Want to improve this question? Upday the question so it's on-topic for muzic-ivan.info Stack Exadjust.

Closed 4 years ago.

You are watching: How old is too old to spank

Here is a tiny even more detail.

I have 2 daughters 8 and 12. We still spank the eight year old and also everything functions well. We quit spanking the earliest probably around age ten and began grounding her and so on.

Now the trouble is the oldest sees that the youngest can take her punishment, cry a little, and also be on her method... and also the earliest really desires to be spanked also because she somehow thinks its easier!

yes by all means we talk, we all calm down nothing is done in anger. We talk about different options next time. The last spanking is done to set points straight and offer an ending to a negative instance. I think so many of you are reasoning it is done like a toddler wbelow you run over and wack there bum to stop a actions which we only did when to speak from running in the street

Improve this question
edited Feb 16 "17 at 15:32
asked Feb 14 "17 at 16:46

9511 silver badge55 bronze badges
RoryAlsop I'm honestly shocked that this would be closed. Spanking is illegal in many parts of the people, and legal in many type of components of the world. I'm personally against it, but banning conversation of it appears to simply reduced off opportunities for rational conversation (and ignores that it has been on-topic for as lengthy as the website existed; am I missing meta discussion?). The inability of world to stop berating or lecturing civilization who have actually various viewpoints to muzic-ivan.info is the problem of the world who can't withstand providing unsolicited advice; it is not the fault of the perkid asking the question.
Mar 21 "17 at 12:33

| Sjust how 7
even more comments

2 Answers 2

Active Oldest Votes
It helps to think about the function of spanking in the discipline toolbox. In my experience, spanking alone is worthless in terms of correcting actions. Parents must define to kids why precisely their behavior is wrong in addition (and generally before) corporal punishment. For circumstances, when our babies tried to bite us (or each other), we"d say "no bite" and also lightly flick their cheek. The goal was to associate the act of biting someone else with an unpleasant feeling and also gain into the habit of teaching fairly than simply punishing.

As our kids have actually grvery own, the education facet has actually become even more necessary. Instead of "no bite", we currently define in full sentences that biting damages various other people. If we use spanking, it comes at the finish of a discussion around what the punishment is for. Gradually, that incredibly conversation becomes the point our kids dreview more than spanking itself. Like your twelve-year-old, my children periodically like a quick spank compared to the conversation about their behavior.

By the moment my earliest was 12, we"d lengthy stopped making use of spanks. At that age, my disapproval was much more efficient than any kind of other develop of punishment. For one of my kids, spanking has actually never operated and ssuggest holding them in my lap. So it requires good judgement to determine if spanking is advantageous or not; age alone isn"t really the determining element.

See more: En Centro De Detencion De Migracion En Texas &Mdash; La Red Hispana

I"d suggest talking via your youngsters about what punishments they think are appropriate. I had this conversation with my earliest and we agreed grounding was not an excellent self-control for him considering that he took pleasure in spending time alone in his room. We agreed that withholding some of his allowance was a better punishment as a basic rule. For my preschoolers, I sell a choice between numerous proper punishments. One pleasant side effect is that they spfinish (a little) much less energy complaining about the punishment and seem even more engaged when I talk with them around their behavior.

I have to additionally point out that spanking can make matters worse if it isn"t grounded with a factor for the punishment or if the parent loses control of their temper. While it"s ideal to discipline as quickly as possible, I"ve occasionally required to simply to walk amethod from the situation until my very own anger is under manage. In the few times I haven"t done that and punished out of anger, I"ve necessary to come ago to my child later to apologize. Again, the key is to emphasis on education quite than punishment.