I understand also that "family" is usually complied with by a singular verb in American English, yet exactly how around the sentence in the title? Is it ok to say "My household is all doctors." in AE?


*

The subject-verb agreement in English is not consistent. Tbelow is essentially no hard-and-rapid dominion governing it unless the variety of a subject is incredibly clear such as he, she, we, they, and so on When a collective noun is supplied, it is as much subjective as it have the right to be and also it totally relies on how you perceive the word.

If you think of "family" as individual household members, you need to use "are".

If you think "family" as a solitary unit, you need to usage "is.

One more point to consider is the topic complement. If it is plural as in your instance (all doctors), it is much better to use "are". If it is singular, it is much better to usage "is".

As the first answer to this ELU question, Are collective nouns constantly plural, or are specific ones singular? argues, there is difference in between American English and also British English.

I choose
BarrieEngland"s answer to the question, My family is or My family members are?:

It would aget depend on just how the family members was viewed. It can be ‘His family were abducted one by one’ or it can be ‘His whole family members was abducted while he was ameans.’


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Apr 13 "17 at 12:38
*

CommunityBot
1
answered Jun 6 "16 at 19:27
user24743user24743
1
Add a comment |
3
Family is a singular collective noun. So, generally, the singular form of verbs is offered through it. In this instance, it would certainly be okay to say that "My family members is all doctors", bereason you"re talking around your one family members.

You are watching: My family and i or me and my family

However before, tbelow are instances in which singular collective nouns are used via the plural form of verbs, mainly as soon as members of the cumulative noun are not in agreement or when they"re not necessarily doing the exact same point.

Here is an excmuzic-ivan.infoent webwebsite via many examples for both instances of singular collective nouns.


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
answered Jun 6 "16 at 16:58
*

keitereth24keitereth24
84744 silver badges1212 bronze badges
2
Add a comment |
0
In short, both versions are grammatical.

To get rid of the confusion, consider the following (from
keitereth24)

Everyone in my family members is a medical professional.

All the human being in my family members are medical professionals.

and this pair (from
BarrieEngland)

His family were abducted one by one.

His entire family was abducted while he was away.


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
answered Mar 25 "20 at 22:47
*

WXJ96163WXJ96163
2,66122 gold badges2121 silver badges6767 bronze badges
Add a comment |
0
My family members are all medical professionals is correct, you must have actually learned this. If you think that it"s "is", then it should be "doctor" rather of "doctors" and also you just have actually one household member. So there"s no correct answer, it depends on your family.

See more: Why Did Maryland Settlers Challenge Lord Baltimore In The 1630S And 1640S?


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
answered Mar 27 "20 at 7:47
*

BubbleberryBubbleberry
1
1
Add a comment |

You have to log in to answer this question.


Highly energetic question. Earn 10 reputation (not counting the association bonus) in order to answer this question. The reputation necessity helps protect this question from spam and also non-answer task.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other concerns tagged singular-vs-plural .


Featured on Meta
Linked
6
"India has" or "India have"
2
A troop of chimpanzees ______ coming in the direction of us ( is/ are)
2
The institution are or the college is?
-4
Use of "Tright here is" or "tbelow are"
Related
8
V-ing and V-ing is vs. V-ing and also V-ing are
6
They love their f***ing household
1
Each and eincredibly among XYZ + singular / plural Verb
0
Do I use "is" or "are" as soon as creating "(an energy) resource is/are the sea waves"?
1
number - All of these words ... are / is to express?
0
"Our content is all around geography quizzes" or "our content are all about geography quizzes"?
0
"All wishes are gone!"
Hot Netjob-related Questions even more warm questions
Inquiry feed
Subscribe to RSS
Concern feed To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and also paste this URL right into your RSS reader.


English Language Learners
Company type of
Stack Exadjust Network
site architecture / logo design © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. rev2021.12.22.41046


English Language Learners Stack Exreadjust functions ideal via JavaScript permitted
*

Your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exreadjust have the right to save cookies on your tool and also disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy.