The Lovely Bones book cover
I am a firm believer before that the book is constantly better than the movie/tv series. I can allude you to multiple examples wbelow the personalities were botched on display screen, or plot holes dominated. The statement that the book is better than the movie commonly holds trueHowever before, through the raised usage of streaming solutions and the increased utilization of publiburned book product being pulled right into the movie/tv world, more and also more of our familiar stories are being put to the display screen, and for this reason being put to the test. Some pass: despite some alterations and also plot alters, the story and characters reprimary reasonably the exact same, which bolsters excitement from the fan base. However before, others don"t, and screenplays that drastically change the storyline leave fans wishing for a do-over.I certainly have some conflicted feelings regarding The Lovely Bonesand its book-to-movie adaptation.I really did like the book. It"s not my favorite, or by any means the ideal book I"ve ever before review, however it was enjoyable and refreshing from what I typically review.

You are watching: The lovely bones differences between movie and book

The Lovely Bones movie poster
If I had to select, though, in between the book and also the movie, I would certainly constantly select the book. In this case, that statement applies. Even though The Lovely Bones movie was good, it left out the majority of components that, for me, simply made the book more unique.The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold is around a 14 year old girl called Susie Salmon that was murdered in 1973 and is told from her perspective as she watches down from "heaven." Susie watches as her family members and friends grieve and also continue on without her, all the while wishing they would certainly find her murderer. It was an exciting idea, and my all at once reaction to the book is that it can have been written much better (the book was 328 pperiods of dense paragraphs) but the resourcefulness of the story is what enabled me to press with.I watched the movie and also my reactivity to that wasa bit different. I felt that it was exceptionally well done, and also it was close to the book in all the important methods except for a crucial few that I assumed identified the personalities in a method that movie-goers would certainly never identify if they didn"t read the book.
Let me define. It did not bother me that some of the occasions were placed out of order, bereason the filmmakers did it in a means that made sense for an adaptation What did bvarious other me, was just how the book covered out over the course of a couple of years (so the sister was younger than Susie once Susie was murdered, however by the finish of the book, the sister was married and also had actually a kid), but the movie condensed it all within a year or two after Susie"s fatality.Imagine all that decision takes ameans.I loved watching the brother and sister growup, grappling through normal life but likewise via the loss of their sister. I liked the troubles that occurred out of that, but considering the movie condensed the timeline,it cut out the supposedly irappropriate bits that humanized the siblings and their battles.
Susie, her dad, sister Lindsey and brotherBuckley dumping their fridge intothe sinkhole
I do not desire to give as well a lot away around the book or the movie while providing my opinions on the adaptation. I just want readers to be made aware that the timeline difference. Tright here is a kind of magic connected in watching the children thrive up that movie-goers won"t get to suffer, which would have been magic I"d have thought should have actually been associated in the adaptation in the initially area.Let"s move onto what the movie did appropriate. In the book, Susie is currently dead, and many her memories are spliced in between scenes in her heaven. In the movie, every one of the memories the filmmaker"s uncovered pertinent (every one of which I agreed with) were put in the front and we didn"t learn Susie was dead till perhaps thirty minutes via. I preferred this, because it didn"t leave most room for confusion.

See more: How Do You Pronounce Koch Brothers In English, How To Pronounce Koch Brothers

Lindsey, inside the residence she"s damaged into,is alerted that someone is downstairs
I likewise chosen that they pulled direct quotes from the book into the movie. Who does not love that? I likewise liked exactly how the last five or so minutes of the movie were pretty much the last 5 or so pperiods of the book. If you want to recognize what I intend by that, review the book and also watch the movie!(*I made notes on distinctions in between the book and also the movie while watching the movie and also I can"t believe just how much was various, yet still somehow the same! I"m never before going to have the ability to write all of this!*)We talked in course around how some characters were changed or melded together or taken out entirely. Tright here was a bit of all of that in tbelow. Ruth, for one, had a different house than the one in the book, yet it made feeling for the movie and saved the majority of explaining. There was a character that already existed in the book, Holly, that was sort of melded into someone else, and also I was shocked when that was revealed in the movie, however I actually really favored it. Tright here was an additional character in the book, Susie"s "death counselor" (or the perboy who welcomed her right into "heaven", I guess is an additional way of placing it) who was taken out entirely, but I didn"t mind that exceptionally much bereason she didn"t have a huge function in the book to begin out via.A few closing thoughts:
Quote from The Lovely Bones
I assumed it was interesting that the movie didn"t go right into excessive information around how Susie"s murderer eliminated her. I currently kbrand-new (having review the book), but all movie goers kbrand-new was that Susie was murdered and the detectives couldn"t find her body.I preferred how every character was a bit different in the movie from their book self, except for Susie. Even if the storyline changed a little bit, in addition to the characters that still lived on earth, I favored exactly how Susie"s dreams and desires still remained the exact exact same.Susie"s "heaven" is very perfect in the movie, but in the book, tright here was a really various idea. In the movie, her heaven was so perfect it was unreal, but in the book, it just appeared choose one more plain civilization through anything Susie wanted.The parents" connection and exactly how it played out in the movie was WAY different than what happened in the book.The scene on once Lindsey breaks right into the residence is specifically like exactly how I imagined it in the book and also kept the same heart-racing pace it was told in in the book.I believed it was exciting just how the movie appeared to centrally emphasis on the family and what they did after Susie"s death because the book shifted focus between the family members and also Susie"s friends. In the movie, Susie"s friends, Ruth and Ray, are even more pumelted to the side as if they were much less essential, but that"s not precisely true.
A grieving Ruth and Ray
These were pretty much all the similarities and also distinctions I found that I thought wouldn"t give away plot points or the end of the story. I wrote a entirety lot even more in notes than all of this, yet I didn"t want to spoil anypoint, so I think everyone have to simply check out this book and also watch the movie so I deserve to share every little thing about what I thought!Overall, the book had actually more than the movie had to offer (conflicted feelings aside), yet the movie was excellent in the feeling that it increased the book a tiny little bit and maintained all the vital components of the story in tact (which is all we have the right to really ask for these days).If you desire a book-to-movie recommendation and aren"t put off by a slightly darker story, pick up The Lovely Bonesthis day and let me recognize what you think. Don"t forobtain to read the book prior to watching the movie, though - you will not regret it!