They don’t simply desire to recognize about news and also the weather. They want to understand about you. So what are 3 things that you have actually going on right now, that you can talk about. Whether it be institution, whether it be an individual connection, whether it be a hobby that you’re connected through.

You are watching: Whether it be or whether it is

My questions:

What is the difference in nuance between "whether it is" and "whether it be"?

Before posting this question, I googled, and some websites say "whether it be" is subjunctive. I do not acquire why it is dubbed "subjunctive". Due to the fact that from what I understand around subjunctive, it"s supposed to be previous of be verb.

If I say "whether it have to be" or whether it would certainly be", is the definition same?


subjunctives connotations
Share
Improve this question
Follow
asked Jan 27 "17 at 14:05
*

ElaungElaung
76333 gold badges99 silver badges1616 bronze badges
Add a comment |

2 Answers 2


Active Oldest Votes
4
Whether it be is subjunctive bereason it represents a conditional, as in the speaker does not recognize your life and also what you will certainly talk about. Whether is a conditional word so it reasons the subjunctive develop of verbs which tfinish to look the very same as the infinitive develop.

However before, in prevalent consumption, whether it is is also acceptable. It is, yet, not taken into consideration as formal. In truth, you deserve to usage the subjunctive or present form after whether and both will be taken.

i.e. "Whether it run rapid or slow." and "whether it runs fast or slow-moving."

The existing tense form is, in my suffer, even more prevalent.

It appears that the subjunctive is even more widespread with exceptionally prevalent verbs favor be or go, and also modals favor can or shall.


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Nov 22 "17 at 21:43
*

CowperKettle
35.9k1414 gold badges116116 silver badges220220 bronze badges
answered Jan 27 "17 at 14:26
*

Curtis WhiteCurtis White
1,68266 silver badges1010 bronze badges
Add a comment |
4
"Subjunctive" is a grammatical category which is quite crucial in miscmuzic-ivan.infoaneous European langueras, however is marginal in English, probably partly bereason in a lot of instances it does not have actually a various create from the plain ("indicative") verb.

The many prevalent survival (which you are probably referring to as soon as you cite the past) is the usage of the "previous subjunctive" for counter-factual conditionals:

If I were a wmuzic-ivan.info-off man, ...

but

If he was a affluent man, ... (not counter-factual: the speaker does not understand whether he was wmuzic-ivan.info-off or not)

This has actually a distinct develop for just one verb in the whole language, and also then only in the first and also third perchild singular: "I/she/he/it were" fairly than "I/she/he/it/was". For any type of various other verb, or any kind of other perkid, it is tantamount from the plain (indicative) form:

If you were there, ...

See more: The Vast Majority Of Cases Heard By Municipal Courts Involve

If they wanted it, ...

both of which might be counter-factual or not.

The other staying subjunctive is the existing subjunctive, which is in eextremely instance similar to the base form (infinitive) of the verb; and also so is distinctive from the indicative just in the 3rd perchild ("give" vs "gives") and in all persons of the verb "to be" ("be" vs "is/are/am"). The a lot of common use of this is in needs and exhortations:

I urge that the committee discuss this!

This usage is especially common in political and also organisational language, and more in Amerideserve to than in British English. Many kind of human being would usage the indicative ("that the committee discusses this"), in ordinary speech.

The usage you are asking about is much less common. I would say that anybody making use of it this day is being deliberately archaic: