As I understand it, the scholarship has actually so much not compellingly answered a far-reaching question of the text of *Romeo and also Juliet*; namely, why the Capulets and the Montagues are at battle. I am encouraged based on my knowledge of Shakespeare"s poetics that an unmistakably correct answer is supplied in the text, yet cleverly and also discreetly.Please carry out the closest hypotheses of which you are mindful - your very own or scholars" - to that "unmistakably correct answer."


You are watching: Why are the capulets and montagues fighting

*

The start prologue just mentions that the feud in between the Capuallows and also the Montagues stemmed from a grudge between the two families.

In the opening of Act 1, we watch that also the existence of a Capulet or a Montague deserve to instantaneously begin a fight bereason of the hatred they felt for each various other.

The new mutiny originates from the trick love affair in between Romeo and also Juliet. The irony is that in Act 1, the leaders of Verona tried to convince Lord Capulet and also Lord Montague to finish their feud because it ongoing to reason disruption by disturbing the peace in Verona.

My interpretation of why I think the feud started is that it is not especially composed, yet it may have actually been a disagreement or a war between the family members bereason Shakespeare mentions "civil blood." this in turn started a generational feud that finished through the deaths of Romeo and also Juliet.


Upvote • 0 Downvote
Add comment
More
Report

Tutor
5.0 (91)

Literature instructor, specializing in Shakespeare


See tutors choose this


See more: Why Does Sand Heat Up Faster Than Water Vs, Why Does Sand Cool Faster Than Water

See tutors favor this

Shakespeare"s plays start in the middle of points (as all excellent stories do). We, as the audience, are entering a story that"s already in the midst of its narration. In the Prologue, we learn that "from primitive grudge break to brand-new mutiny" (line 3). The feud is old yet the fighting has actually newly damaged out again. We do not understand why. The Prologue likewise sets up the truth that these are 2 families that are incredibly comparable. They both reside in Verona. They are rich and established households -- "both aprefer in dignity" even. For all practical objectives, they should be allies fairly than adversaries.

The following hint that we obtain originates from the Prince in Act 1 Scene 1. The Prince, after breaking up the fight in Act 1 Scene 1, states: "And hear the sentence of your moved prince./Three civil brawls, bred of an airy word." Very newly, 3 various public fights have actually damaged out among the Capulets and Montagues. The feud between the two households has actually become public and violent sufficient for the Prince to concern about the safety and security of his people and his city.

I would certainly argue that"s component of the tragedy: We don"t recognize why they are fighting, hence we can not totally understand what would be at the exceptionally root of why Romeo and also Juliet can not be together. Shakespeare sets the play in the warmth of Verona, Italy. The days are lengthy and also warm, hence mirroring the moods of the citizens. They are physically hot and also they are hot via anger -- little bit points can collection them off. More than anything, Shakespeare is reflecting a harsh light on humanity: Humans host grudges. We host prejudices and also hate in our hearts that occasionally can"t also be defined by ourselves. The tragedy of Romeo and also Juliet is that it does not have to finish in tragedy, but it does.