Jan. 23, 2013— -- For decades, the standard logic has organized that unions and also miprovide labor do not mix.

You are watching: Why did some labor unions oppose immigration

Cesar Chavez, the Mexican Amerihave the right to labor hero, opposed the usage of unrecorded immigrants as "scabs" and also also had actually union members form a "wet line" at border crossings to intimidate Mexihave the right to workers crossing into the U.S.


See Also: Obama and also Rubio Immigration Plans: What"s the Difference?

But tbelow are indications that labor unions are currently onboard via comprehensive immigration redevelop. And after they split over recreate in 2007, the two best union groups, the AFL-CIO and also Change to Victory, have actually agreed to a widespread set of values.

Unions have plenty of factors to assistance reform, according to a current post in Talking Points Memo. Immigration recreate would increase pay for low-wage workers, and that can result in increased union enrollment. And many unions have actually undocumented immigrants members, prefer the Service Employees Internationwide Union (SEIU), which represents employees in fields favor home healthcare and also janitorial solutions.

In addition, unions feel they have actually an achievable political muzic-ivan.infoal in recreate. Eliseo Medina, secretary treasurer of SEIU, told Talking Points Memo that after being "anti-immiapprove or at leastern anti-undocumented immigrant" with the mid-1990, the unions have actually adopted a new tone on immigration, and are prepared for a legislative victory. The country"s biggest teacher"s union, the National Education Association, likewise supports immigration reform. According to Medina, that implies the substantial majority of union members nationwide desire a readjust in immigration policy.

But unions aren"t on the very same web page as some various other pro-recreate teams once it concerns one potential aspect of reform: guest worker programs.

President Obama and also Florida Sen. Marco Rubio both mentioned guest employees as part of their early on outlines for immigration redevelop, yet unions oppose what they"ve referred to as "indentured" worker programs.


Republicans and pro-recreate businesses think about guest employees a crucial item of recreate. And if President Obama"s early plans are any indication, Democrats may be open to the idea, also.

The union stance on guest worker programs has break-up their coalition prior to. In 2007, the AFL-CIO opposed a recreate initiative through a guest worker regime, while SEIU determined to assistance it. The bill eventually died in the Senate. That concern might fray the coalition this time approximately, as well.

Alengthy via the opposition to guest employees, AFL-CIO and also Change to Victory outlined their five values of immigration reform in 2009, a blueprint they"re still utilizing today:

1. An independent commission to manage future flows of immigrants

The unions believe that the future circulation of legal immigration requirements to be versatile and able to respond to the needs of the labor market. They assistance setting up an independent commission that would recognize the variety of short-term and also long-term visas making use of guidelines from Congress.

2. Effective workarea enforcement

The blueprint calls for a mandatory system to verify whether employees are eligible to work in the UNITED STATE A federal regime, E-Verify, does that currently, but it has actually been criticized for inaccuracy and also inefficiency. Some supporters of redevelop have said an additional option: revamping Social Security cards to make them harder to counterfeit. The outline says it"s also crucial that the worker verification device "has adequate due procedure and also privacy protections and also prevents discrimination."

3. "Rational" control of the border

The unions anxiety that they want a "rational" method to border protection. Their major point is that an enforcement-only technique to immigration won"t work-related, and also that any type of enforcement strategy requirements to incorporate various other parts of recreate, favor enhanced streams of legal employees. Any immigration enforcement on the border, the blueprint states, "need to respect the dignity and rights of our travellers, and also residents in border neighborhoods."

4. A course to legal status for the 11 million undocumented

The blueprint claims that till undocumented workers can obtain legal standing, they"ll continue to drive down weras for legal workers. Whether that legal condition implies citizenship or something else isn"t proclaimed, but the unions desire a reasonable and accessible process that urges people to apply.

5. No new guest worker programs.

See more: Crystal Field The Crystal Field Splitting Energy, Δ, A) Is Larger For Tet

One of the ethics that sets the unions acomponent from pro-recreate business groups is their stance on guest employees. The unions oppose brand-new guest worker programs, and also instead think future flows of immigration have to be regulated by the independent commission outlined over. The blueprint cites the "limited civil and employment rights" of guest employees. While not mentioned in the outline, the subtext is that guest workers -- maybe functioning without healthtreatment or other benefits -- can drive down salaries for native-born workers. Even existing guest worker programs must be reformed, according to the SEIU"s Medina. Due to the fact that guest workers are tied to a single company with their visas, "employers use that to thrconsumed and also control workers," he said.