Home > Learn > Educational Resources > Historical Documents > Perspectives on the Constitution: A Republic, If You Can Keep It


Our engaging, dynamic exhibits and programs are aligned with state and also national requirements so you deserve to connect your field expedition with your classroom curriculum.

You are watching: Why did the period of national harmony end

Downpack the Guide to Standards-Aligned Exhibits & Programs.

By Ricdifficult R. Beeman, Ph.D.

While this particular day we marvel at the extrasimple achievement of our Starting Fathers, their very own reactivity to the US Constitution as soon as it was presented to them for their signatures was significantly less enthusiastic. Benjamin Franklin, ever before the optimist also at the age of 81, gave what was for him a remarkably restrained assessment in his final speech prior to the Constitutional Convention: "…as soon as you assemble a variety of guys to have actually the benefit of their joint wisdom, you inevitably assemble with those males, all their prejudices, their passions, their errors of opinion, their regional interests, and also their selfish views." He believed it difficult to suppose a "perfect production" from such a gathering, but he thought that the Constitution they had simply drafted, "through all its faults," was better than any kind of alternate that was most likely to emerge.

Nat an early stage all of the delegateways harbored objections, yet persuaded by Franklin"s logic, they put aside their misgivings and afaddressed their signatures to it. Their over-riding worry was the tendency in nearly all parts of the young country toward disorder and also disintegration. Americans had actually offered the doctrine of famous sovereignty--"democracy"--as the rationale for their effective rebellion against English authority in 1776. But they had not yet functioned out fully the question that has actually plagued all countries aspiring to autonomous government ever before since: exactly how to implement ethics of well-known majority ascendancy while at the very same time maintaining steady governments that defend the rights and also liberties of all citizens.

Few believed that a brand-new federal constitution alone would certainly be sufficient to produce a linked country out of a collection of independent republics spcheck out out over a huge physical space, extraordinarily diverse in their financial interests, neighborhood loyalties, and ethnic and spiritual attachments. And there would certainly be brand-new indicators of disorder after 1787 that would certainly remind Americans what an infinish and also unsteady nationwide structure they had created: settlers in western Pennsylvania rebelled in 1794 bereason of taxes on their in your area distilled whiskey; in western North Carolina there were abortive attempts to develop an independent republic of "Franklin" which would ally itself via Spain to insure its independence from the United States; there was continued problem with Indians throughout the whole western frontier and raised are afraid of servant unremainder, particularly as soon as news of the slave-led rdevelopment in Haiti reached Amerihave the right to shores.

But as breakable as America"s federal edifice was at the moment of the founding, there was a lot in the culture and atmosphere that contributed to a nationwide consensus and cohesion: a widespread language; a solid belief in the ethics of English prevalent regulation and also constitutionalism; a widespcheck out commitment (albeit in diverse forms) to the Protestant religion; a common revolutionary experience; and also, maybe a lot of vital, an financial setting which promised a lot of cost-free, white Americans if not excellent riches, at leastern an independent sufficiency.

The Amerihave the right to statesmales who succeeded those of the beginning generation served their country via a self-aware sense that the difficulties of preserving a democratic union were every bit as great after 1787 as they were before. Some elements of their nation-building program--their proceeding toleration of slaincredibly and genocidal policies towards Amerihave the right to Indians--are fit objects of nationwide shame, not honor. But statesmen of being successful generations--Lincoln foremost among them--would continue the quest for a "more perfect union."

Such has actually been our success in structure a powerful and cohesive autonomous nation-state in post-Civil War America that most Americans today assume that principles of democracy and also nationwide harmony somejust how normally go hand-in-hand also. But as we look about the remainder of the people in the post-Soviet era, we uncover ample proof that democratic revolutions do not inevitably lead to national harmony or global justice. We check out that the expression of the "renowned will" have the right to produce a cacophony of discordant voices, leaving many kind of baffled about the true definition of majority dominion. In much too many locations approximately the civilization now, the expression of the "popular will" is nopoint more than the unleashing of primordial forces of tribal and religious identity which better conuncovered the goal of structure stable and consensual federal governments.

As we look at the state of our federal union 211 years after the Founders completed their work-related, tright here is cause for satisfaction that we have avoided many of the plagues afflicting so many various other societies, however this is hardly cause for complacency. To be certain, the US Constitution itself has not only made it through the dilemmas confronting it in the previous, however in so doing, it has actually in itself end up being our nation"s most powerful symbol of unity--a far preferable different to a monarch or a national religion, the establishments on which the majority of countries about the world have actually relied. In addition, our Constitution is a more powerful, better record than it was once it initially emerged from the Philadelphia Convention. Thunstable the amendment procedure (in specific, via the 13th, 14th, 15th and also 19th Amendments), it has actually become the protector of the legal rights of all the people, not simply some of the people.

On the various other hand also, the difficulties to national unity under our Constitution are, if anypoint, far higher than those confronting the infant country in 1787. Although the brand-new nation was a pluralistic one by the requirements of the 18th century, the challenge of America in 1998 looks very different from the original: we are no much longer a people joined by a widespread language, faith or culture; and while our as a whole level of material prosperity is staggering by the criteria of any age, the widening gulf in between rich and also negative is probably the many major hazard to a common interpretation of the "search of happiness."

The conditions that thrconsumed to weaken our feeling of nationhood, bound up in the debate over slaincredibly and also shown up in intense sectional problem during the pre-Civil War era, are now both even more facility and also diffusage. Several of today"s problems are component of the tragic tradition of slavery--a racial climate noted too often by mutual mistrust and also misexpertise and also a condition of despeprice poverty within our inner cities that has actually left many kind of young people so alienated that any kind of traditional interpretation of citizenship becomes meaningmuch less. More frequently, however in the long run probably just as alarming, tens of millions of Americans have actually been turned-off by the corrupting effects of money on the political system. Bombarded with negative declaring about their candidays, they express their feelings of alienation by continuing to be home on election day.

If tright here is a leskid in all of this it is that our Constitution is neither a self-actuating nor a self-correcting document. It requires the consistent attention and devotion of all citizens. Tbelow is a story, often told, that upon exiting the Constitutional Convention Benjamin Franklin was approached by a team of citizens asking what sort of government the delegateways had produced. His answer was: "A republic, if you have the right to save it." The brevity of that response need to not cause us to under-worth its important meaning: democratic republics are not merely founded upon the consent out of the civilization, they are likewise absolutely dependent upon the active and increated involvement of the human being for their continued excellent wellness.

See more: Why Do My Shoulders Hurt When I Drink Alcohol ? Why Does My Shoulder Hurt After Drinking Alcohol

Dr. Rictough Beeman is professor of history and also dean of the College of Arts and also Sciences at the University of Pennsylvania. The University is NCC"s academic companion, and also for the year 1997 – 98. Dr. Beemale serves as vice chair of our Distinguiburned Scholars Advisory Panel.